Poor Safety = Higher Premiums. Here’s Why It Matters.

When your company’s safety record slips, your insurance premiums rise—sometimes drastically. And while most companies know this in theory, few take the necessary steps to understand how to prevent it.

Insurance providers base premiums on risk. If your organization has a pattern of incidents, claims, or OSHA citations, you’re seen as a high-risk client. This doesn’t just increase the cost of general liability or workers’ compensation—it also affects your eligibility for bidding on contracts, particularly in government or large-scale industrial work.

This post explores how poor safety performance leads to rising insurance costs and what you can do to take back control.

How Poor Safety Records Drive Up Premiums

• Frequent Workplace Incidents: Claims related to injuries, property damage, or equipment failure trigger cost adjustments.
• High EMR (Experience Modification Rate): This key metric, calculated from your claims history, directly influences your workers’ comp rates.
• Inadequate Safety Programs: Insurers may penalize companies that lack formal training, documentation, or corrective action systems.
• Regulatory Violations: Fines and penalties from OSHA, DOT, or EPA signal poor compliance—and increase perceived risk.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

Every incident, no matter how small, becomes part of your claims history. And over time, the financial consequences add up:

• 20–40% higher premiums over competitors with clean safety records
• Limited options from insurance providers
• Exclusion from bidding opportunities requiring low EMR thresholds

But it’s not just about money. Poor safety performance hurts morale, damages your brand, and makes it harder to attract skilled workers.

What Insurers Want to See

Insurance companies reward organizations that demonstrate proactive risk management. That means:

• Documented safety programs and SOPs
• Regular training and hazard awareness initiatives
• Prompt reporting and resolution of incidents
• Evidence of audits, inspections, and continuous improvement

Some insurers even offer discounts or preferred rates to clients who implement advanced safety systems, including real-time monitoring, ISO 45001 certification, and digital compliance tracking.

1.    Build a Safety Program That Pays Off

To reverse the trend of high premiums, start by improving the foundation of your safety program:

2.    Conduct a Safety Program Audit

Identify gaps in documentation, training, and reporting that affect your insurability.

3.    Track and Analyze Near-Misses

Reducing claims starts with identifying patterns in non-injury incidents before they escalate.

4.    Digitize Your Compliance and Reporting

Use platforms that track training, inspections, and corrective actions. A well-documented system builds trust with insurers.

5.    Engage Workers in Safety Ownership

Involve employees in daily inspections, toolbox talks, and reporting. A committed team helps reduce incidents across the board.

6.    Monitor and Improve EMR and KPIs

Make your EMR a monthly conversation. Improve it through consistent hazard control, claims management, and contractor oversight.

What Key Safety LLC Offers

At Key Safety LLC, we help organizations:

• Reduce incident frequency through targeted SOPs and training
• Build audit-ready safety documentation systems
• Improve EMR through incident reduction and program alignment
• Present safety metrics that strengthen insurance negotiations

Stop Paying for Unsafe Practices

A poor safety record is expensive—but it’s also fixable. With the right tools, training, and support, your company can lower its risk profile, qualify for better insurance rates, and compete more effectively.

📩 Subscribe to our newsletter for practical ways to reduce safety-related costs.

🔍 Visit Key Safety LLC to build a program that improves safety—and your bottom line.